Fossil Group's fiscal third-quarter results are the first sign in years that the legacy watchmaker may be stabilizing. The company reported operating income of $25.3 million, against an operating loss of $21.7 million a year earlier, and net sales rose 0.4% to $271.2 million. Those are modest numbers, but after a long slide they matter. The company also said it returned to net income of $11.7 million, or 19 cents per share, compared with a net loss of $39.9 million, or 76 cents per share, the year before.

The strategy behind the figures is straightforward, and CEO Franco Fogliato has described it plainly. He said the company shrank to a sustainable baseline by closing stores, pulling back from promotions and focusing on full-price sales, while cutting operating expenses 11.1% to $137 million. Direct-to-consumer sales fell 5.9% in the quarter, which Fogliato attributed to what he called an "aggressive" downsizing. A smaller business that earns more per sale is a defensible plan, but it is a different thing from a business that is growing its way back.

The most encouraging detail is the return of traditional watches. Smartwatch sales came in under $1 million, while analog watches, which make up around 86% of sales, grew 6.4%. Fossil spent years chasing the smartwatch trend and was hurt by it. Walking away from that fight and betting on the product it knows best is a sound call. The 15.1% growth in Asia, which Fogliato said was led by India, also suggests the brand still has demand outside its home market.

Still, the caution should be stated plainly. The company's full-year guidance of $980 million to $990 million in net sales would mark a decline from just over $1 billion the prior year. The company also said it had not expected sales growth for another year and a half, so this quarter came earlier than planned. Fogliato's claim that the turnaround is ahead of plan is a claim about his own schedule, and one quarter of growth cannot establish a trend. The stock, trading under $8 a share, has lost most of its value since the early-to-mid 2010s, which is a reminder of how far there is to recover.

Investors and readers should judge Fossil on the next two or three quarters, not on this one. The test is whether sales keep growing, whether full-price selling holds without markdowns returning, and whether the company reaches the positive free cash flow it has promised by year's end. If those things happen, the comeback will have earned its name. Until then, Fossil has made a credible start, and the company deserves credit for the discipline, but the word turnaround should be earned rather than announced.