McDonald's reported third-quarter results that look good on the surface but hide a weak core. Its U.S. restaurants, open at least 13 months, posted a 0.2% decline in same-store sales. That is a slight drop, and it still beat the 0.5% decline that analysts expected, according to a StreetAccount survey. Beating a low bar is not the same as recovering. The shares closed more than 6% higher on Wednesday, which tells you investors were relieved more than they were impressed.
The report's strongest numbers came from abroad. Same-store sales rose 1.5% overall, lifted by international segments, and the international developmental licensed markets, including Japan and China, grew 4.2%. Yet the international operated division, which includes Australia and Germany, rose only 1.4% against a projected 2.1%. France was described as a weak spot, with a softer economy and student protests cited as drags. Growth that depends on markets outside the United States is useful, but it does not answer the question shareholders should be asking about the home business.
CEO Chris Kempczinski said the U.S. business was encouraged by improvement as the quarter progressed after the company's intervention on value. That may be true. The report also notes that McDonald's same-store sales fell in July and August before returning to growth in September, and that Kempczinski acknowledged in August that execution was falling short, particularly on value offerings. CFO Ian Borden clarified on the call that he had not said U.S. same-store sales would be better in the fourth quarter. A single month of growth is a reason for cautious hope, not a turnaround.
The company's response is sensible but slow. It is leaning on Extra Value Meals and app-based promotions aimed at its most frequent diners, and it is testing two new value menus. The winning concept will not reach the full U.S. system until early 2027. Discounting has become the industry's default answer to budget-conscious customers, and McDonald's has leaned on it for two years. Shareholders should press management on whether value can rebuild traffic without eroding margins, because lower prices that only hold volume steady are a treadmill, not a strategy.
My judgment is that the market rewarded a better-than-feared quarter and a mention of improvement, which is a reasonable reaction but an incomplete one. McDonald's should show sustained positive U.S. same-store sales before anyone calls the domestic business fixed. Until then, the earnings beat should be read as a pause in the decline, not proof of recovery.