For two years the restaurant industry has talked about value as if it meant little more than a lower price on the menu board. The report describes a different and more durable idea. Chains are now sending their corporate chefs back into the kitchen, betting that a better product will win back diners who have grown pickier and eat out less often, based on data from Black Box Intelligence. That is the right bet, and the industry should have made it sooner.

Discounts and one-off promotions can lift traffic for a while, but they do not explain why a customer returns a month later. The report notes that the product itself still matters for long-term growth and for franchisee profitability. Franchisees are the people who absorb the cost of promotions and the cost of new equipment, so a chain that cannot give them a menu worth selling is asking them to pay for growth that never arrives.

The evidence in the report is encouraging. Domino's changed its recipe in 2009 and recorded U.S. same-store sales growth of 9.9% the following year. Burger King's revamped nuggets and Whoppers were followed by a double-digit percentage rise in Whopper sales and a jump of more than 35% in nugget sales, with U.S. same-store sales up 8.4% in the quarter. Those are company-reported results, and a single quarter does not prove a trend. Still, they show that customers respond when a familiar item tastes better.

Wendy's deserves a harder look. The report says the chain reported its seventh straight quarter of same-store sales declines on the same day it rejected a $1.4 billion takeover bid from Trian Partners, led by Nelson Peltz, and argued the bid ignored the value of its turnaround. Better bacon and a richer Frosty are sensible, but investors will want to see sales recover before accepting that the turnaround has started. Quality claims are cheap until the registers say otherwise.

My recommendation is simple. Chains should publish clear, measurable results from each menu change, including traffic and franchisee margins, not only praise from executives on earnings calls. They should also train the people who make the food, as McDonald's is doing with its "Make It Golden" program, because a recipe that is not executed well is not an improvement at all. Diners will notice the difference, and they will reward the chains that keep their promises.